A Fun Exercise Using Thrulines--Descendants of Jabel Putman

I am fortunate to have tested myself and three of my siblings in an effort to capture the DNA we inherited from our Dad.  He passed away before autosomal DNA (atDNA) testing was widely available. That gives us four of his children who have tested. Each child received 50% of their DNA from him, but not the same 50%. Because of this, sometimes all four of us will share a common match. Other times, only one of us will have the match.

The table below shows the number of tested Jabel Putman descendants that Thrulines believes are connected through each child's branch, broken out across the four siblings. This was primarily a visual exercise in identifying potential connections through Jabel's children,  so I did not double-check every match. If you use this exercise to infer a connection through a Thruline ancestor, you will need to verify each connection independently. The table is a great illustration of the randomness of DNA inheritance. 

Jabel Putman(1772-1835) is my 3rd Great-Grandfather.  He was from Union County, South Carolina, before moving to Bedford County, Tennessee.

Things to remember:  

• Thrulines uses users' trees, and those could likely have errors that other trees have copied.
• Thrulines is side-blind and doesn't verify that the match is on the side of the family that would make the suggested connection possible.
• Thrulines links smaller segment matches, which may be false positives / identical by state and not by descent.

To make sure the Thruline suggestion is even possible:  

• Look at the shared matches you have with the DNA match connected with the Thrulines. Do they share with other known matches of that line?
• Is the match even on the correct side to make the Thrulines possible?
• Green dotted lines between each connection from the Thruline Ancestor to the DNA match indicate that it is a hypothesis and should be checked as thoroughly as possible before being used to make any inferences. The match may be connected through an entirely different line.

Studying the Thrulines gives you a better understanding of the matches because it forces you to prove or disprove the possibility of the connection through that match or line, which helps your overall research. Just as you never really know who might have the most Putman or Cook DNA, you also don't know who might have sources or clues to help with your research. Locating cousins can be very helpful, especially if they are actively researching. Everyone who tests isn't. I feel like this table will also be a helpful reference when I want to work on Jabel's line.

John W Manire (1855-1924) of Bellville, St. Clair County, Illinois

John W Manire is my 1C3R

Retired Dentist Died Suddenly of Apoplexy

John W. Manire, 68 years old, a retired dentist, died suddenly at his home, 17 South 13th street, this morning at 10 o'clock, following a stroke of apoplexy. Manire, although complaining of rheumatism in his arm, was apparently in good health this morning. While seated in a chair by the stove in the kitchen of his home, he had been discussing family affairs with his wife, when he suddenly gave an exclamation of pain and collapsed in his chair. His wife hurriedly summoned some of the neighbors, who notified her son and also called a physician.

When the two arrived a short time later they found that the man had died. Deputy Coroner Albert Baldus held the inquest this afternoon and a verdict of "death, due to apoplexy" was returned by the jury. The deceased was born in Tennessee, September 19, 1855, a son of Mr. and Mrs. John W. Manire. He was united in marriage to Miss Maggie B. Minter, February 17, 1875. Besides his widow, he is survived by the following children: J. L. Manire, Mra. L. Sharber, of White Plains. Ky.: Mrs. Anna Woodson, B. L. and H. C. Manire, of this city, and Mrs. Willie Wilson, of Providence, R.I. The funeral will be held Wednesday afternoon at 2 o'clock from the residence to Walnut Hill cemetery..

"Retired Dentist Died Suddenly of Apoplexy", Belleville Daily Advocate, May 19, 1924,  p 1, col 4; image,  Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/belleville-daily-advocate-john-w-manire/193400604/ : accessed March 14, 2026), clip page for John W Manire(age 68) Retired Dentist Died Suddenly of Apoplexy.

Three Marriages and a Westward Journey: The life of James Polk Cook (1836–1888)

James Polk Cook was born on October 13, 1836, the son of William Clifford Cook and Elizabeth Putman Cook. The family was living in Bedford County, Tennessee at the time of his birth but were enumerated in Dyer County, Tennessee by the 1840 U.S. Federal Census. They were back in the middle Tennessee area by the following year, as shown in the school census, with James's older sister Minerva attending school in Williamson County, Tennessee, District 25. James was likely still living with his family at the time of the 1850 U.S. Federal Census, when he would have been around thirteen years old. We cannot confirm this with certainty, however, as the Bedford County, Tennessee District 10 enumerations have been lost.

Between 1858 and 1867, James entered into three distinct marriages.  He first married Messina "Cenia" Ann Bailey on August 6, 1858, in Rutherford County. By the time of the 1860 census, James was enumerated living in his parents' home without his wife. When the Civil War began, he enlisted on August 24, 1861, in Company A, 24th Tennessee Confederate Infantry, serving as a wagoner. He was sick for much of his service and was eventually discharged in June of 1862 at Tupelo, Mississippi. In April of 1865  his union with Cenia was legally dissolved in Bedford County, with her desertion cited as the reason.

Only months after his divorce, James sought a fresh start, marrying Harriet Hamer on October 12, 1865, in Williamson County. This union remains something of a genealogical mystery. While it is widely believed that Harriet passed away shortly after the marriage, given the lack of children and James's remarriage within two years. However, the records do not explicitly state how this union ended. James' brother, Gideon had married Mary Hamer, a sister of Harriet, and she too had passed away not long after giving birth to their only child, a son named Robert Cook.

On December 20, 1867, James married Susan Carson Ferguson in Rutherford County. This union finally provided the stability James had long sought, lasting twenty-one years until his death and producing three children: Harriet Sophie (1869), Minerva Mae (1870), and William C. (1873). Susan's children from her first marriage, John R. Ferguson and Tennessee ("Tennie") Ferguson, became integral members of the household. However, their presence in historical records creates a fascinating puzzle for researchers. In both the 1870 and 1880 censuses, John R. and Tennie are listed with the surname Cook. To a casual researcher, it might appear they were James's biological children or had been legally adopted. Other records  such as Tennie's marriage license clearly use the name Ferguson, however. This highlights a common nineteenth-century nuance: census takers often recorded everyone in a household under the head-of-household's surname for simplicity. It is a good reminder that the name on a census isn't always the legal reality.

Following the 1880 census, James and Susan, along with others of the Cook family, relocated to the Franklin County, Arkansas area. William Green Hight, a maternal first cousin of James's father had previously moved to the Washington & Madison Counties of Arkansas area and had also ended up in Franklin County, where he died in 1881(around the same time the Cooks were heading that way). We know the family had arrived by late 1881, as James's stepdaughter Tennie and Joseph Knox Cook's daughter Melzora both married on November 15, 1881. James appears on the Mulberry Township tax list for Franklin County in 1882. His brother Joseph Knox Cook is also on the same tax list for Mulberry Township that year, though his entry is noted as not paid. By 1884, James is listed on the White Oak Township tax list in Franklin County. Joseph does not appear on any further Arkansas tax lists. Whether John R. Ferguson accompanied the family to Arkansas remains unknown, as no records have been found that positively identify him there. Records for Tennie, Harriet, Minerva Mae, and William C. have been located.

James's mother had died in the fall of 1880, and when the family departed for Arkansas, it would be the last time James saw his father, William Clifford Cook, who passed away in January of 1882. James himself died in Franklin County, Arkansas, on August 19, 1888, and is buried in Highland Cemetery in Ozark.

Sources:

Williamson, Tennessee, School Census 1838-1939, District 25, William C Cook 1 child(Over 6<16); digital images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CS1W-9QXZ-K?cat=823595 : accessed 9 April  2024), Image  1067 of 5811; citing Genealogical Society of Utah, 1998  Film 2115582 Item 2, DGS 8411324.

"1840 US Census"  Dyer County, Tennessee,  p. 104, Household of Wm C Kook(Wm C Cook); database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33SQ-GYBJ-96TR : accessed 12 March 2026), IGN 5154899, Image 212 of 1013.

"Rutherford, Tennessee, United States records," 1856-1861, marriage register, p 54, James P Cook and Cenia Ann Bailey, 6 August 1858; images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-L93F-MSLY : accessed 12 March 2026), IGN 5725214, .image 728 of 971.

Bedford County, Tennessee, Circuit Court Minutes, 1864-1865, IGN 8659576, Image 172-3 of 672, Bill of Divorce, James P. Cook vs. Messina Ann Cook, State Case #6331 & #6332 (April Term 1865), pp. 283-284; digital images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QHV-D3C6-49Z9-4 : accessed 7 April 2024).[This is James P Cook's divorce from Cenia Ann Bailey]

"Williamson, Tennessee, United States records," marriage bond, James P Cook and Miss Harriet G Hamer, 12 October 1865; digital images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QSQ-G93F-SRXF : accessed 9 Apr  2024), image 1331 of 1649; IGN 5725450, Williamson County Archives (Franklin, Tennessee).[I believe that Harriet died not long after the marriage]

"Williamson, Tennessee, United States records," marriage license, James P Cook and Miss Harriet G Hamer, 12 October 1865; images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QSQ-G93F-SRCY : Apr 10, 2024), image 1329 of 1649; IGN 5725450, Williamson County Archives (Franklin, Tennessee).

"Tennessee, U.S., Compiled Marriages, 1851-1900, "database, J P Cook and Susan Ferguson, 20 December 1867, Rutherford County, Tennessee; citing  database, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/discoveryui-content/view/31525:4125 : accessed 10 April 2024);

Cook Family Bible Record, 1834–1857; "WC Cook Bible Family Records p 1," James P Cook's date of birth listed as Oct 13th, 1836;digital image, shared by Marie Cooke Beckman, 11 Mar 2026, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/mediaui-viewer/collection/1030/tree/77121678/person/46358454391/media/b3646cdd-dc1a-4e4b-af70-e3601a05099c : accessed 11 Mar 2026); privately held by descendants of Cass B Cook.

1860 U.S. census, Bedford County, Tennessee, population schedule, Western Division District 10, Rover Post Office, page 115(penned),  dwelling 860, family 814, James Polk Cook living in Household of W C & Elizabeth Cook; imaged "United States Census, 1860",  FamilySearch  (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33S7-9BSF-9M1B : accessed 7 April 2024).

1870 U.S. census, Bedford County, Tennessee, population schedule, District 10, pg 31(penned), dwelling 211, family 211, James and Susan Cook; imaged, "United States Census, 1870,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MD8F-ZLC : accessed 7 April 2024).

1878 Beers Map, J P Cook listed in Dist 10 of Bedford County TN, Library of Congress(https://www.loc.gov/item/2006626023/ : accessed 13 Mar 2026)

1880 U.S. census, Bedford County, Tennessee, population schedule, Enumeration District 10, pg 12(penned), dwelling 102, family 103, James and Susan Cook; imaged, "United States Census, 1880,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33SQ-GYBH-YK1 : accessed 7 April 2024).

"Arkansas, County Marriages, 1837-1957," database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HT-6LL9-653 : accessed 13 May 2024), Entry for Hugh Clawson(age 20)  and Tennessee Ferguson(age 18), 15 November 1881.

Franklin Co Arkansas Ozark Tax Records 1882, 1884, 1886 & 1887, Mulberry Twp. , p 27, J K Cook(not marked paid) and J P Cook; images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSK7-RSNQ-M :  accessed 12 March 2026),
IGN 8139953 Image 32 of 621.

Franklin Co Arkansas Ozark Tax Records 1882, 1884, 1886 & 1887, White Oak Twp.,  p (none), J P Cook, ; images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSK7-RSJL-P : accessed 12 March 2026), IGN 8139953 Image 264 of 621.

"Arkansas, County Marriages, 1837-1957," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HT-6LL9-X6N : accessed 13 May 2024), Entry for H F Hill and Tennessee Ferguson, 1 September 1886.

Minerva Cook Boyce(Jul 26th 1834 - Apr 23rd 1900) Bedford Co. TN

Death Notice of Mrs. William Boyce(nee Cook)

From Baptist and Reflector publication (9th Aug 1900)

Placed by the Union Ridge Church Committee.

BOYCE.- Mrs. William Boyce (nee Cook) died at her home in Bedford County on Monday evening, April 23, 1900, aged 65 years, 8 months and 28 days. She professed faith in Christ in her youth and united with the Union Ridge Baptist Church, and lived a consistent member of the same till she was called from her earthly home to that rest which remains for the people of God. She leaves seven children and a number of relatives and friends to mourn their loss. Her husband was called to his eternal home just eight months ago. Sister Boyce lived a very active life. She was a kind neighbor, a generous friend, an earnest Christian, a devoted mother, never tiring in her efforts of administration in her family. We commend the grief stricken friends to our heavenly Father, who doeth all things well for our good and his glory. Done by order of the Union Ridge Church June 23, 1900. Jane Thomason, Martha Smotherman, Lena Chick, Committee.

Minerva Cook Boyce was the oldest child of William Clifford Cook and Elizabeth Putman Cook. Although the death notice does not identify her by her given name, the information it contains clearly refers to her and reflects a life filled with many roles within her family and community beyond simply that of “Mrs.” She was the second wife of William Moody Boyce. When Minerva married William, his children by his first wife, Elizabeth Smotherman, were all under the age of eleven, and Minerva helped raise them along with the four children she and William had together.

This death notice is the first record I have found that provides evidence for her exact date of death. Photocopies of the family records page from the William C. Cook family Bible record her birth date, while her gravestone lists only the years of her birth and death. Together, these sources now provide complete dates for both events. I could also check for probate files or deed transfers which might also name the date to add to the sources.

Sources:

• Baptist and Reflector, August 9, 1900, p 7, col 4; image, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/baptist-and-reflector-minerva-cook-boyce/193142998/ : accessed March 11, 2026), clip page for Minerva Cook Boyce obituary by user rmbeckman.
• Wm Clifford Cook Family Bible Record, Page Contents covering 1834–1857; "Wm C Cook Bible p 1," digital image of photocopy(1997), shared by Marie Cooke Beckman, 11 Mar 2026, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/mediaui-viewer/collection/1030/tree/77121678/person/46358454391/media/b3646cdd-dc1a-4e4b-af70-e3601a05099c : accessed 11 Mar 2026); Bible pages privately held by descendants of Cass B Cook, youngest son of Wm Clifford Cook.
• Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/134283363/minerva-boyce: accessed March 11, 2026), memorial page for Minerva Cook Boyce (1834–1900), Memorial ID 134283363, citing Simpson Cemetery, Bedford County, Tennessee, USA; Maintained by rmbeckman (contributor 48136157).

Some of the new features at Ancestry

Trying out a few of the new features at Ancestry that were announced at RootsTech 2026.  I had the Ideas button for a bit but it is no longer showing on my account.  It didn't work very well for my tree and kept suggesting things I already had.  I do not have access to the Transcription tool because my level of subscription is US Discovery(I'm Colonial American on both sides & that level works better for me)   I do have several other of the new tools that were announced at RootsTech.

Ancestry's new Census Hint Comparison feature.
My 2nd Great Grand Uncle Henry Frizzell's census records

Discover Insights of Gallery Images

Hoping this new feature will catch on and help folks add descriptions, dates, image type and locations to their images.  If you have any of the fields blank it will offer Insights generated by clicking on the Insights Button(shown below).

  

Once the insights are generated the user has the option of saving or removing the generated text. I like that it explains how it came up with the location.  It was correct so I chose to save it.

The generated description was also correct.  The picture was of my Dad, with a hospital gown over this clothing so that he could hold his first child.  It did a very good job on this.  You can get an Insight to any of the fields if you clear them and then refresh the page.

The Insights Tool will be a good function to have if you plan on using their new digitization service,  AncestryPreserve. Ancestry delivers those digitally preserved files to your gallery. You will be able to add info to them just as you would any other uploaded files.

Ancestry has also streamlined the adding source citation process.  Hopefully this will encourage folks to add a source since it is a lot easier to do.  It is better to have some type of source citation than NO source citation.  I'm so happy to see this. I've never done change well but this change is something I am all for.

Also the Ancestry AI has been around for awhile.  You can ask it questions and have it interrupt 1950 census data and a number of other files.  The issues I run into with it are when the transcription is riddled with errors and / or my ancestor just out right lied.  Then some of the things it comes up with a not so great because they don't match what I know was happening within the family.  As far as I could tell any corrections I had added were not considered when generating the AI insights.  For me it was better on what was going on in the general area rather than within the family. 

RootsTech 2026--Day 3

RootsTech Day 3

Sat. March 7, 2026

Announcements & Sales

Today was the last day of RootsTech 2026.  I really loved the advanced classes this year.  That said, I did feel like there was a larger disconnect than normal for the #NotAtRootstech attendees. Don't forget to check the online Expo Hall for sales.  Many of them end at midnight tonight.  Next year, RootsTech will be March 4-6, 2027.  Mark your calendars.

My session selection today was focused mainly on methodology.  These were just the classes that I viewed. There are many more available. For more in-depth information on the day's events check out any of the classes or online expo hall at the RootsTech website.  Even if you miss the deals be sure to come back and check out the many online sessions available free online.

Saturday Sessions (4)

• Advanced/Professional  Mar 7, 9:00 AM CST  DNA Analysis Methodology: Defeat the Genealogy Gremlin–Karen Stanbary

• Advanced/Professional  Mar 7, 10:30 AM CST  Wanted! Seeking the Identity of Unknown Parents –Dana Palmer 

• All Levels  Mar 7, 01:15 AM CST  New Ancestor Connector Tool with 21,000 19th-century People Researched –Sara Eagle Briggs  &  Kristy Wheelwright Taylor

• Advanced/Professional  Mar 7, 2:30 PM CST  Question Everything: Sharpen Evaluation, Avoid Assumptions, & Clarify Your Writing  –Kelley Conner Lear