Wanted to make sure I get all of my research on these three men up to this point published. A very rough draft of the research---
The following are 3 Davis Men whose identities get tangled and my attempt at sorting thru them. Researching them shows they are three individuals and two of them my be brothers but that is not yet proven. I wanted to publish what I have so far. Hopefully will be able to get more on each of them and add when I can.
Birth: 8 May 1876
1880 Census: Age 3 w/ Lucinda GrMAdaline & Unc John
1900 Census: Need to Find Saw one earlier of him and Sarah
1910 Census: Luther Davis Age 32 Van Buren Co TN Mom listed as Louisa Hale 3 of 3 Children?
1920 Census: Luther Davis Age 44 Madison Co AL
1930 Census: E. Luther Davis Age 53 Madison Co AL
1940 Census: Luther Davis Age 63 Warren Co TN
1950 Census: ----
Death Cert or Obit: 1949 (Feb 21)
"Alabama, Deaths, 1908-1974"", FamilySearch
(https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:J6S2-1ZD :
accessed 27 Oct 2026), Lucendia M. Hale in entry for Elzie
Luther Davis, 1949."
Parents: William M Davis and Lucinda M? Hale
(https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:J6S2-1ZD :
accessed 27 Oct 2026), Lucendia M. Hale in entry for Elzie
Luther Davis, 1949."
Parents: William M Davis and Lucinda M? Hale
FHL 1908837
No Idea why it says M as middle initial have always heard it was
and that is what it is on Census
Wife: Sarah Sally Evans Davis
Notes: Death Rec gives YOB as 1878
Regarding the Wm M Davis vs Lucinda C Davis divorce
in Bledsoe Co TN 1884 Lucinda's Brother, Wm and her
Sister Mary both had families living in Bledsoe Co TN
Dist 1 in the 1880s
In the 1910 Census for Luther where Lucinda is living with
him and listed as Louisa Hale the number of children says
3 of 3. Though in later one says 2 of 2.
It is interesting to note that Elzie Luther Davis names his youngest
son Luther Floyd Davis(Middle name of Lucious)
Lucinda C Hale Davis' Alabama Death Record lists her parents
names as well as her Husband at this point I only have access
to the index which contains those but want to get copies of the
original of her AL DC and Elzie Luther Davis' death record.
Alabama, Deaths, 1908-1974,"" index, FamilySearch
(https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/JDKR-YJ9 : accessed
28 October 2026), Lucinda Catherin Davis, 02 Aug 1919; citing
reference cn 403, Department of Health, Montgomery;
FHL 1908211."
Just a rough run down on what is known about each of them for any Davis and Hale researchers who are dealing with them.
No Idea why it says M as middle initial have always heard it was
and that is what it is on Census
Wife: Sarah Sally Evans Davis
Notes: Death Rec gives YOB as 1878
Regarding the Wm M Davis vs Lucinda C Davis divorce
in Bledsoe Co TN 1884 Lucinda's Brother, Wm and her
Sister Mary both had families living in Bledsoe Co TN
Dist 1 in the 1880s
In the 1910 Census for Luther where Lucinda is living with
him and listed as Louisa Hale the number of children says
3 of 3. Though in later one says 2 of 2.
It is interesting to note that Elzie Luther Davis names his youngest
son Luther Floyd Davis(Middle name of Lucious)
Lucinda C Hale Davis' Alabama Death Record lists her parents
names as well as her Husband at this point I only have access
to the index which contains those but want to get copies of the
original of her AL DC and Elzie Luther Davis' death record.
Alabama, Deaths, 1908-1974,"" index, FamilySearch
(https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/JDKR-YJ9 : accessed
28 October 2026), Lucinda Catherin Davis, 02 Aug 1919; citing
reference cn 403, Department of Health, Montgomery;
FHL 1908211."
Robert Elzie Davis
Birth: 29 Jan 1872
1880 Census: Age 8 Madison Co AL in HH of Oliver & Willie Davis
1900 Census: Age 28 Etowah Co AL with wife Leona Bell Davis
1900 Census: Age 38 Madison Co AL
1900 Census: Age 47 Hamilton Co TN
Death Cert or Obit: Died 5 Mar 1944
Parents: Oliver Davis and Willie Duncan (Death Cert) Wife informant
Wife: Mary Ethel Davis(2nd Wife)
Notes: Moved from Huntsville To Chattanooga 1934
Obit mentions surviving siblings which doesn't
fit either of the other Davis men.
Sisters
Mrs. T. L Holder (Huntsville)
Mrs. B. F. Brock (Tuscumbia)
Brothers
Herman Davis (Huntsville)
Ollie Davis (Birmingham)
Retired Railroad Man in the Huntsville Obit (no
mention in Chattanooga Obit about Railroad work)which
differs a bit from the Chattanooga one but does
name his sisters and brothers
Lucius Floyd Davis
Birth: 24 July 1874
1880 Census: Age 6 with Wm M Davis Bledsoe Co TN Dist 9
1900 Census: Age 25 Bledsoe Co TN Dist 1
1910 Census: Age 33 Bledsoe Co TN Dist 2
1920 Census: Age 45 Bledsoe Co TN Dist 1
1930 Census: Age 56 Bledsoe Co TN Dist 1
1940 Census: Age 65 Bledsoe Co TN Dist 1
1950 Census: Age 75 Bledsoe Co TN Dist 1
Death Cert. or Obit: "His Death Cert with wife as informant
gives his parents names as Wm M Davis
and Lucinda Hale
""Tennessee, Deaths, 1914-1966"", FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QKMS-MVN9 :
accessed 27 Oct 2026), Lucius Floyd Davis, 17 April 1959."
Wife: Nancy Johnson Davis
Notes:
The divorce in 1884 Bledsoe Co TN between Wm M Davis and Lucinda C Davis
is that of Lucinda C Hale. Had I saw the 1880 Census without census records of
later years I might have thought that it was a duplicate one for Luther but given
that there are entries for Lucious Davis in later years these are two individuals
Luther(1876) and Lucious(1874) whose death certificates claim the same parents
I found a FindAGrave profile for Wm M Davis father of Lucious Davis and it had a
bio which said that Lucinda Hale was his 3rd wife and they had one son together.
This seems a bit odd. I guess there could have been another Lucinda Hale but the
the divorce in Bledsoe Co TN(which was not mentioned in bio) listed her as Lucinda C.
and that is what Wm Taylor Hale & Adaline's daughters name was.
I am showing DNA matches from those who descend from Elzie Luther Davis and his
half brother James Monroe Bishop. To my knowledge Lucious Floyd Davis had no issue
so there shouldn't be anyone who descends from him if he is a full brother of Elzie
Luther Davis. "
